The Challenges of Indifference: A Unit Genocide Using Night and Left to Tell

About Franchesca Warren

For fifteen years Franchesca taught English/Language Arts in two urban districts in Atlanta, Georgia, and Memphis, Tennessee. Increasingly frustrated with decisions being made about public education from people who were not in the classroom, in 2012 she decided to start a blog about what it was really like to teach in public schools. In the last four years, The Educator's Room has grown to become the premiere source for resources, tools, and strategies for all things teaching and learning. To learn more about Franchesca Warren's work, please visit www.franchescalanewarren.com.

“Never shall I forget that night, the first night in camp, which has turned my life into one long night, seven times cursed and seven times sealed.

Never shall I forget that smoke. Never shall I forget the little faces of the children, whose bodies I saw turned into wreaths of smoke beneath a silent blue sky. 

Never shall I forget that smoke.

Never shall I forget the little faces of the children, whose bodies I saw turned into wreaths of smoke beneath a silent blue sky. 

Never shall I forget those flames which consumed my faith forever.
Never shall I forget that nocturnal silence which deprived me, for all eternity, of the desire to live.

Never shall I forget those moments which murdered my God and my soul and turned my dreams to dust.

Never shall I forget these things, even if I am condemned to live as long as God Himself. Never.”            —Night (Elie Wiesel)

Elie Wiesel, a Holocaust survivor and author who fought for peace and human rights  died on July 2nd, 2016 at the age of 87. While everyone will remember his fight for human decency,  I would like to remember his work through the eyes of my World Literature students. Up until 8 years ago, I had never taught the text, Night, nor had I extensively covered the Jewish Holocaust, but as fate would have it, my principal moved me to World Literature and now I was “tasked” with not only covering the text but making it interesting to my classroom full of students in inner-city students in  Atlanta. I knew they needed to learn about this horrible time in the world, but I had to figure out a way to engage my students.

After scouring numerous used bookstores, I finally had my companion text, Left to Tell by Immaculee Illbiszaga.

Shocking the Students into Caring

I wish I could say my students were uber excited to learn about world events, but in a time when most students were more concerned with Facebook statuses than social justice, I decided to take a road less traveled and I decided to shock them into caring. I opened up the unit with two pictures- decades apart but told similar sufferings and before I allowed the students to say anything they had to annotate the pictures for meanings.

So, the first day of the new unit in October, I  projected two screens (side by side) in my classroom and for the warm-up students had to annotate the pictures for meanings.

Rwandan Genocide

The aftermath of bodies after the Rwandan Genocide.

Elie Wiesel

Elie Wiesel at Auschwitz as a teenager.

Both images haunting as they were projected on my screen dually (and color copies on each of my groups) I could hear students talking. “What the hell happened here?” Are these people sick? Is that a man or woman?” Did someone get murdered? This must have happened a hundred years ago, but why does picture look recent? Finally frustrated with my lack of answers and their natural teenage curiosity, one student turned to me and said, “What is this and what does this have to do with English/Language Arts?”

I used this opportunity to give them a little bit of background of the photos but explained to them that our unit would focus on two central texts by Illbizaga and Wiesel and before we did anything else we would need to understand the word genocide.

According to the National Holocaust Museum, the word holocaust was created in 1944 and refers to,

violent crimes committed against groups with the intent to destroy the existence of the group. Human rights, as laid out in the US Bill of Rights or the 1948 United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights, concern the rights of individuals.

This definition brought a lot more questions as my students wanted to know so I divided the students into pairs and using the standard 10RL1 (Citing Textual Evidence) I gave students the article, “Redefining Genocide” and they had to annotate and answer six text-dependent questions that would make them go “deep” into why the term was coined.

Research About Genocides 

Once all students understood the definition and had a good understanding of the article on Redefining Genocide, I then allowed the students to go further into citing textual evidence and research, I gave students a hodgepodge of articles about various genocides and had them complete a WebQuest on their finding(s).

WebQuests  Note: These WebQuests are just starting points. Revise them as you need to cover the standards of your unit. 

20th/21st Centuries Genocides  

What is Genocide?

More

During this phase of about a week, the classroom would get very “heavy” with emotion as we research, discuss, and process the worse of human nature. Students ask questions some  days and other days they just want to “get done”. No matter how the kids feel, I always bring the research with the same question- How did indifference make the (insert genocide name) possible? By the time students are finished, they are ready for the next level of learning- reading the text(s).

Read Alouds for Critical Points 

Traditionally, I always started with the Rwandan Genocide text, Left to Tell, because it’s easier to read and students move through it quickly. Taking a page from my elementary and middle school counterparts, I always read the preface of the text, Left to Tell word for word and by the time I finished kids were on the edge of their seat with anticipation.

  • What happens next?
  • Was she a Hutu or Tutsi?
  • Why is she in a closet?
  • What’s a machete?

Since I had them hooked, I then gave them a structured reading schedule and for the next month, we used this text to teach the standards 10RI1-3.

Field Trips and Guest Speakers

While our days were busy reading the selected texts, I arranged field trips and guest speakers to help my students understand that genocide is real. While we were 4 weeks into the unit, we had transitioned from Left to Tell to Night and my students were more than curious about Mr. Wiesel’s story. I used a multitude of resources found at the Jewish Holocaust Museum and The Breman Jewish Heritage Museum for my kids to meet real survivors of the Holocaust.

Our first field trip to the later, my students were silent as they respectively observed the artifacts. To top things off we had the pleasure of listening to a survivor tell their story and answer questions for the students. The conversations that this person shared with us was immeasurable and brought my students to tears.

IMG_0810 IMG_0808

Videos and Other Media Rich Texts

During this genocide unit, the “bread and butter” of my unit was a collection of videos and photos that brought my students into the horrors of ethnic cleansings. At first, my students shuddered and didn’t believe they were real but as we read both texts they realized that there are atrocities that happen in this world that we can’t even comprehend. Here are a list of resources I used during this unit:

This just a glimpse of what I did during this nine-week unit but what my students learned will be with them for a lifetime. As a matter of fact, when news broke the Mr. Wisel had passed one of my former students sent me the following text message.

“Did you hear that that author, Elie Wiesel, died? I’m actually sad. His book was so sad. I hope he’s finally in peace.You know because of that book, I’ve taken several mission trips across the world trying to speak for people who have no voice.” 

I had succeeded, my students understood that indifference is just as evil as murder.

Genocide

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
By |2016-11-01T13:46:31+00:00August 3rd, 2016|Instruction&Curriculum|0 Comments

About the Author:

For fifteen years Franchesca taught English/Language Arts in two urban districts in Atlanta, Georgia, and Memphis, Tennessee. Increasingly frustrated with decisions being made about public education from people who were not in the classroom, in 2012 she decided to start a blog about what it was really like to teach in public schools. In the last four years, The Educator's Room has grown to become the premiere source for resources, tools, and strategies for all things teaching and learning. To learn more about Franchesca Warren's work, please visit www.franchescalanewarren.com.

Leave A Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.