• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Advertising
  • Write for Us
  • Job Board
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
    • Consulting
    • Advertising
  • Shop
    • Books
    • Shirts

The Educators Room logo

  • Start Here
    • Impact Statements: Teacher Expertise
    • Newsletter
  • Browse Topics
    • Content Strategies
      • Literacy
      • Mathematics
      • Social Studies
      • Educational Technology
      • ELL & ESOL
      • Fine Arts
      • Special Education
      • Popular Topics
        • Teacher Self-Care
        • Instructional Coach Files
        • Common Core
        • The Traveling Teacher
        • The Unemployed Teacher
        • The New Teacher Chronicles
        • Book Review
        • Grade Levels
          • Elementary (K-5)
          • Middle (6-8)
          • Adult
          • New Teacher Bootcamp
          • Hot Button Topics
            • Menu Item
              • Principals' Corner
              • Charter Schools
              • Confessions of a Teacher
              • Interviews
              • The State of Education
              • Stellar Educator of the Week
            • Menu
              • How to Fix Education
              • Featured
              • Ask a Teacher
              • Teacher Branding
              • Current Events
  • Podcasts
  • Courses
    • Practicing Self-Care to Avoid Teacher Burnout- An 8 Week Course
    • Becoming An Educational Consultant
    • Teacher Branding 101:Teachers are The Experts
    • The Learning Academy
    • Books
    • Shirts
  • Education in Atlanta
  • Teacher Self-Care
  • The Coach's Academy
menu icon
go to homepage
subscribe
search icon
Homepage link
  • Advertising
  • Write for Us
  • Job Board
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
    • Consulting
    • Advertising
  • Shop
    • Books
    • Shirts
×

December 9, 2012 From the Front Lines

Do Teachers Have Freedom of Speech?

  • About the Author
  • Latest Posts

About Yoshana Jones

Yoshana B. Jones, Esq. is an educator and Professional Learning Facilitator with Fulton County Schools. She leads the professional development of educators lead PLCs at Westlake High School. For the 2013-2014 school year, Coordinate Algebra students experienced at 11% gain on the state standardized test. Ms. Jones is committed to educational equity for all students. She is the Chair of the new PLC Development team, which is dedicated to providing opportunities for teachers to learn and grow as professionals. In addition to her work with students, Ms. Jones is the Owner of Good Samaritan Apparel, LLC. Good Samaritan Apparel is a Christian t-shirt company that hopes to spread love, joy, and the Word. Ms. Jones writes inspirational blog posts that encourages Christian believers to remain full of faith.
  • Michigan Student Prevails in First Amendment Claim against Teacher - July 17, 2013
  • Michigan High School Bans Athletic Prayer - July 9, 2013
  • Surviving Teach for America: What I Learned from the Corps - July 2, 2013
  • Supreme Court Rules on Affirmative Action Case - June 26, 2013
  • The First Amendment and Student Dress Codes - April 15, 2013
  • Testing Pressure Leads to a Criminal Indictment - April 1, 2013
  • Planning for the Future: Special Needs Students' Transition Plan - February 20, 2013
  • Protecting the Protectors: Limited Liability from Students’ Lawsuits - February 14, 2013
  • Teacher Tenure- An Ancient Policy Or Is It Still Needed? - January 8, 2013
  • Are More Gun Control Laws Needed? - December 31, 2012

The First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution guarantees many freedoms. It guarantees the right to publish news (freedom of press), the right to practice or not practice a religion (freedom of religion), the right to request a course of action from the government (freedom of petition), and the right to gather to express your views in a non-violent way (freedom of assembly). The First Amendment also guarantees the freedom of speech.

The protections of the freedom of speech are often misunderstood by those who do not recognize its reach. I had a student who once told me that he did not have to stop talking in class because he was exercising his First Amendment right to free speech. Well . . . not quite! Like any right guaranteed in the Constitution, the First Amendment right to free speech is not absolute. It has some restrictions that may require a curtailment of a citizen’s speech.

The first limit of freedom of speech is that it does not apply to all types of employees. The First Amendment states that “Congress shall make no law . . . abridging the freedom of speech . . . .” Therefore, the Constitution provides explicit protection for government employees only, which obviously includes teachers.

So, does that mean that teachers can say whatever they want and claim the protections of the First Amendment? The answer should be a resounding no. The fear of termination based on speech and expression has caused many teachers to take great lengths in hiding their online social networking sites and writing education articles under a pseudonym. Teachers and school employees are obviously aware that the First Amendment has some boundaries.

In Garcetti v. Ceballos, 547 U.S. 410 (2006), the Supreme Court outlined a two-prong test to determine whether a public employee engaged in constitutionally protected speech. First, the court will determine whether the employee spoke as a citizen on a matter of public concern. This question analyzes whether the employee spoke as a citizen or pursuant to official job duties. If the employee did not speak as a citizen on a matter of public concern, then the employee is not entitled to the protections of the First Amendment. Second, the court will determine whether the government body had an adequate reason for treating the public employee differently from any other member of the general public. This question analyzes whether the employee’s speech was outweighed by the state’s interest in promoting efficiency.

Imagine the following case:

A state statute requires that history courses infuse more African and African-American history into the curriculum. A history teacher in that state believes that a local school district is failing to require other history teachers to infuse African and African-American history into the curriculum. Thus, the history teacher voices his concerns at various school board meetings. Subsequent to his speeches at the board meetings, the teacher was transferred many times to different schools and eventually terminated. He believed that he was terminated because of his critic of the district’s implementation of the state statute.

The previous scenario is based on Sherrod v. School Board of Palm Beach County, 703 F. Supp.2d 1279 (S.D. Fla. 2010).

In this case, the court ruled that Mr. Sherrod (the history teacher) was speaking as a citizen on a matter of public concern at the board meetings. His official job duties did not include curriculum development or ensuring that the district complied with the state statute. Furthermore, the court ruled that Mr. Sherrod’s speech outweighed the government’s interest in efficiency. Mr. Sherrod presented his concerns a public board meeting. His concerns did not affect the harmony at the schools where he worked. In addition, he was the father of two children in the school district; therefore, he was also speaking as a concerned parent.

The following factors will help teachers understand whether their speech is constitutionally protected:

(1) The speech touches on a matter of public concern. (This is a requirement. If the speech does not touch on a matter of public concern, then the speech is not protected.)
(2) The teacher’s speech outweighs the school district’s interest in efficiency. The courts may consider such factors as:
- Whether the speech affects the harmony of the staff
- Whether the speech has a detrimental impact on working relationships
- Whether the speech interferes with the normal operation of the employer’s business.

Public school teachers are in a unique position. They are individuals and employees of the state. Therefore, school districts have an interest in making sure that the messages that students receive are in line with the district’s goals and vision.

Editor's Note: If you enjoyed this article, please become a Patreon supporter by clicking here.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Related posts:

Firm Decisions Before an IEP Meeting May Violate the IDEA The Deafening Silence of Teachers A Letter to My Students On First Amendment Rights Turning The Page on Tragedy
« A Pocket Full of Assessments: Using Quick SIOP Strategies to Check for Understanding
Let's Just Sit Down and Talk! The Socratic Discussion: Creative Implementation of Common Core Assessment »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Dan McConnell says

    December 10, 2012 at 4:51 am

    What if the district's goals and vision have come under control of entities openly and willingly criticizing the job the district and its teachers are doing?

    Reply
    • Yoshana Jones says

      December 11, 2012 at 5:38 am

      As with many things in the law, whether the teacher's speech is protected by the First Amendment depends on the unique circumstances of each case. For example, if the teacher is speaking about their dislike of a principal, a court will likely deem this as unprotected under the First Amendment because it does not speak to a matter of public concern. If, for example, a teacher is speaking out about the need to engage in more rigorous instruction in math, a court may deem this protected speech because it touches on a matter of public concern and the teacher's speech may outweigh the district's interest in efficiency.

      Reply
  2. sarah says

    December 24, 2016 at 4:05 pm

    What if a teacher makes a comment on her private and personal FB page about the presidential election? She says something like Trump won because he doesn't give a hoot about safe spaces and gender neutral bathrooms? She was accused of using inflammatory language and terminated.

    Reply
    • Ashley L. says

      July 10, 2017 at 4:20 pm

      Hi Sarah,

      If the teachers page was linked with the school's webpage, even by saying they work at "school name" or "school district" then their Facebook page is seen as representing the viewpoints of that school or district. If that was the case, the school and district have every right to terminate this teacher, even if they have tenure.

      Reply
    • جمیل حسین says

      April 29, 2019 at 7:07 am

      This is also my concern.. What if a teachers speaks for more democratic norms , like local body elections etc..

      Reply
  3. Dante P says

    January 16, 2017 at 4:10 pm

    Under a "Anti Harrassment Policy", if a student found the teachers teachings offensive to him/her, would this lesson or teaching be abolished? (If this were to take place on a public college or university campus)

    Reply
  4. Sam says

    August 27, 2017 at 12:36 pm

    What if the teacher wrote a book critiquing the common core, professional development, and certain teacher evaluation rubrics? What if in that book the teacher referred to things that happened to him at work but didn't use any names?

    Reply
  5. dan skinner says

    December 05, 2017 at 11:52 am

    In the 9th Circuit, there is a limited exception for teachers.

    We hold that academic employee speech not covered by Garcetti is protected under the First Amendment, using the analysis established in Pickering. The Pickering test has two parts. First, the employee must show that his or her speech addressed “matters of public concern.” Pickering, 391 U.S. at 568, 88 S.Ct. 1731; see Connick, 461 U.S. at 146, 103 S.Ct. 1684. Second, the employee's interest “in commenting upon matters of public concern” must outweigh “the interest of the State, as an employer, in promoting the efficiency of the public services it performs through its employees.”

    Demers v. Austin, 746 F.3d 402, 412 (9th Cir. 2014)

    Reply
  6. Robyn Henning says

    May 19, 2019 at 1:47 pm

    What if a teacher is saying that it is amoral and against Gods plan to be homosexual.
    What if a teacher has said in class that abortion is wrong under any circumstance and he would make his wife have that baby.
    Neither of these teachers are health teachers.

    Reply
  7. Christine Mathurin says

    October 05, 2019 at 12:48 pm

    What if a teacher is quietly reading his bible on his desk during quiet reading time. His students are reading quietly and he chooses to do his own reading during this time. Does he have the right as per the First Amendment?

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Primary Sidebar

The Educator's Room was launched in 2012 to amplify the voice of educators. To date, we have over 45+ writers from around the world and boast over twelve million page views. Through articles, events, and social media we will advocate for honest dialogue with teachers about how to improve public education. This mission is especially important when reporting on education in our community; therefore, we commit our readers to integrity, accuracy, and independence in education reporting. To join our mailing list, click here.

What we do

At The Educator's Room, we focus on amplifying and honoring the voice of educators as experts in education. To date, we have over 40 staff writers/teachers from around the world.

Popular Posts

  • How to Incorporate SEL Into Any Content Area
  • A Q&A with Baltimore Teachers Union President, Diamonté Brown
  • 6 Reasons to Use Read-Alouds Daily
  • The Secret Ingredients of Lesson Planning

Featured On

Buy Our Books/Courses

How to Leave Your Job in Education

Practicing Self-Care to Avoid Teacher Burnout

Using Your Teacher Expertise to Become an Educational Consultant

Check out our books on teaching and learning!

The Learning Academy

Footer

↑ back to top

About

  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Accessibility Policy

Newsletter

  • Sign Up! for emails and updates

Contact

  • Contact
  • Services
  • Media Kit
  • FAQ

 

Copyright © 2021 The Educator's Room.